Practical guide
Who pays for damage an owner causes to common parts
When a single owner causes damage to a common part, for example ruining the entrance gate while maneuvering a car or damaging the facade with unauthorized work, the repair cost does not follow the ordinary allocation criteria. It is not split among everyone by thousandths, but falls entirely on the party who caused the damage, based on the liability for wrongful act under Article 2043 of the Italian Civil Code. The condominium often advances the repair for reasons of urgency, then acts in recourse. This guide explains how to establish liability, how to document it and how to recover the sum from the responsible owner.
The principle: the one who causes the damage pays, not the condominium
The thousandth allocation of Articles 1123 and following concerns the preservation and enjoyment costs of common parts, not damage caused by wrongful conduct. When damage is caused by a single person's behavior, the civil liability of Article 2043 applies: anyone who causes another an unjust damage is obliged to compensate it. The repair cost is therefore entirely charged to the responsible party.
It would be unfair to make all owners pay for the repair of damage caused by only one. The rule applies whether the wrongdoer is an owner, a family member, a guest or a person for whom the owner is responsible. The condominium as a community must not bear the financial burden of a single person's wrongful act.
How liability is established
The delicate point is proof. To charge the full cost to the alleged responsible party you must prove the link between their conduct and the damage. Concrete elements are needed: witness statements, video surveillance images in compliance with privacy law, reports, photographs of the state of the premises and any technical assessments.
Absent certain proof, the condominium manager cannot unilaterally decide to charge the expense to an owner. If liability is contested, the matter may require a judicial assessment. Documenting the event promptly is therefore decisive for the success of the recourse.
The manager's role and advancing the cost
The condominium manager has the duty to preserve the common parts and may act to repair damage, especially where it is urgent to avoid dangers or worsening. In many cases the condominium advances the repair cost with common funds, so as not to leave the damaged common asset, subject to later recovering the amount from the responsible party.
Before advancing significant sums it is advisable to inform the meeting and gather documentation of liability. The manager, within the powers of Articles 1130 and 1135 of the Italian Civil Code, acts to protect the common asset, but non-conservative expenses and compensation require attention to the limits of the manager's powers and to the meeting's competence.
Recovering the sum and the role of insurance
Once liability is established, the condominium asks the owner to reimburse the advanced amount. If the responsible party does not pay voluntarily, a formal request follows and, if necessary, a recovery action. It is important to keep this item separate from ordinary condominium contributions: it is not an allocation share, but a claim arising from a wrongful act.
Insurance often comes into play. The owner's civil liability policy, or the condominium's comprehensive building policy with possible recourse, may cover the damage. The manager must check the coverage, open the claim promptly and keep all documentation useful to support the request.
Keeping the responsible owner's position orderly
Managing individual damage means keeping the item distinct: advanced amount, documentation of liability, communications, any insurance claim and reimbursement. Mixing this sum with ordinary contributions generates errors in the budget and the financial statement.
With software such as AmministraPro the manager can record the advanced expense, link it to the responsible owner as a distinct claim and track communications, claim and reimbursement, keeping the financial statement clear. The features are described on the /funzioni page and the plans on the /prezzi page.
Frequently asked questions
Is damage caused by one owner split among everyone?
No. The repair of damage caused by a single owner's conduct falls entirely on the one who caused it, based on the liability for wrongful act under Article 2043 of the Italian Civil Code, and does not follow the thousandth allocation criteria of common expenses.
What is needed to charge the damage to the responsible party?
You must prove the link between their conduct and the damage with concrete elements: witness statements, video surveillance images in compliance with privacy, photographs, reports and any assessments. Without certain proof the manager cannot unilaterally charge the expense; if contested, a judicial assessment may be needed.
Can the condominium advance the repair cost?
Yes. To preserve the common asset, especially in urgent cases, the condominium often advances the repair with common funds, subject to later recovering the amount from the responsible party. It is prudent to inform the meeting and first gather documentation of liability.
Does insurance cover damage to common parts?
Often yes. The owner's civil liability policy or the condominium's comprehensive building policy, with possible recourse, may cover the damage. The manager must check the coverage, open the claim promptly and keep the useful documentation.
How do I keep this expense separate in the statement?
It must be treated as a claim from a wrongful act toward the responsible owner, not as an allocation share. Software such as AmministraPro lets you record the advance, link it to the responsible party and track reimbursement and claim: the features are on /funzioni and the plans on /prezzi.
Try AmministraPro
Accounting, thousandths-based cost splitting, meetings, communications and artificial intelligence in a single Italian software, compliant with UNI 10801 and GDPR.