Practical guide
How to handle an insurance claim denial in a condominium
A claim does not always close with an indemnity: the company may deny coverage or reduce the amount, arguing that the coverage does not apply, that the damage falls within an exclusion, that the notice was late or that the appraisal is below expectations. For the manager a denial is not the last word: it is the start of a phase in which one must understand precisely the reason for the refusal, verify whether it is well founded against the policy and the law, and decide whether to challenge. Reacting methodically, between written observations, an own-party appraisal, a complaint to the company and to IVASS and possible legal action, can recover the indemnity or at least reduce the part that will fall on the owners.
What to do faced with a denial
- Get the exact reason for the denial or reduction in writing
- Reread the policy to verify the coverages, exclusions and deductibles invoked
- Check that the claim was filed within the deadlines and through the right channels
- Gather evidence and quotes that dismantle the reason for the refusal
- Submit written observations and, if needed, an own-party appraisal
- Activate the complaint to the company and, if unsuccessful, to IVASS
- Inform the meeting and, if appropriate, resolve on legal action
- In the meantime prepare the allocation of the unrecovered part
Understanding the reason for the denial
The first step is to obtain in writing the exact reason for the refusal or reduction. The typical causes are few: the coverage does not apply because the event is not covered, the damage falls within a policy exclusion, the notice was deemed late against Article 1913 of the Italian Civil Code, or the appraisal is lower than the damage claimed. Each of these reasons is addressed differently, so you cannot react without knowing it precisely.
With the reason in hand you reread the policy, general conditions included, to understand whether the refusal is well founded. Exclusions often have precise boundaries, and damage that seems excluded may actually fall within coverage if it is framed correctly. Careful reading of the contract is the basis of any challenge.
Challenging with observations and an own-party appraisal
If the denial appears unfounded, the manager can submit written observations to the company, attaching the evidence that dismantles the reason: photos and reports proving the covered dynamics, documents attesting the timeliness of the notice, quotes that correctly quantify the damage. In cases of disagreement over the estimate, an own-party appraisal is useful, that is, the assessment of a technician appointed by the condominium, which can counterbalance that of the company's adjuster.
Many policies also provide the contractual appraisal procedure, with one expert per party and possibly a third expert, to resolve differences over quantification without going to court. Activating these tools shows that the condominium does not accept the denial and, at the same time, builds the documentation useful for any subsequent action.
Complaint to the company and to IVASS
Insurance companies must handle complaints according to the sector regulation. The manager can therefore send a formal complaint to the company's complaints office, which must reply within the set deadlines. If the reply does not arrive or is unsatisfactory, it is possible to turn to IVASS, the insurance supervisory authority, filing a complaint with the documentation of the matter.
The complaint to IVASS does not replace legal action and has no value as a judgment, but it is often a useful step: it prompts the company to reconsider its position and leaves a record of the conduct held. Alternative dispute resolution systems, where provided, may also offer a faster route than a trial. The choice among these paths depends on the size of the damage and the strength of the condominium's position.
Deciding on legal action and managing the outcome
When the denial stands and the stakes are significant, the condominium can act in court against the company to obtain the indemnity. The decision to start a case, with the related legal and appraisal costs, belongs to the meeting, which also resolves to grant the manager the mandate to litigate under Article 1131 of the Italian Civil Code. The limitation periods of the rights arising from the insurance contract under Article 2952 must be considered.
Whatever the outcome, the manager must in the meantime handle the unrecovered part of the damage: if the indemnity does not arrive or is reduced, the repair cost returns to the owners and must be allocated under Article 1123. With AmministraPro the manager keeps in the loss record the denial, the observations, the own-party appraisal, the complaints and the resolution, linking each step to the accounting that will handle the allocation of the uncovered part. The features are described on /funzioni and the plans on /prezzi.
Frequently asked questions
Must the insurer give reasons for denying the indemnity?
Yes, the company must communicate the reasons for the refusal or reduction, and the manager has an interest in obtaining them in writing in order to challenge them. The typical reasons are the coverage not applying, a policy exclusion, the lateness of the notice against Article 1913, or an appraisal lower than the damage. Knowing the exact reason is essential, because each of these causes is addressed differently and you cannot react effectively without knowing what the company bases the denial on.
What can I do if I consider the denial unfounded?
The manager can submit written observations to the company attaching the evidence that dismantles the reason, such as photos, reports and quotes, and, in case of disagreement over the estimate, activate an own-party appraisal entrusted to a condominium technician. Many policies provide the contractual appraisal procedure, with one expert per party and possibly a third expert, to settle differences over quantification without going to court. These tools show that the condominium does not accept the denial and build the documentation useful for any subsequent action.
How does the complaint to IVASS work?
Insurance companies must handle complaints according to the sector regulation. The manager first sends a formal complaint to the company's complaints office, which must reply within the set deadlines; if the reply is missing or unsatisfactory, they can file a complaint with IVASS, the supervisory authority, with the documentation of the matter. The complaint to IVASS has no value as a judgment and does not replace legal action, but it prompts a reconsideration of the position and leaves a record of the conduct held by the parties.
Who decides whether to sue the insurer?
The decision to act in court against the company, with the related legal and appraisal costs, belongs to the meeting, which also resolves to grant the manager the mandate to litigate under Article 1131 of the Italian Civil Code. Before proceeding, the strength of the position, the size of the damage and the limitation periods of the rights arising from the insurance contract under Article 2952 must be assessed. A solid own-party appraisal and orderly documentation strengthen the condominium's position in court.
What happens to the repair cost if the indemnity does not arrive?
If the indemnity is denied or reduced, the unrecovered part of the damage returns to the owners and the repair cost must be allocated according to the nature of the common part involved and the criteria of Article 1123 of the Italian Civil Code. The manager must handle the challenge to the denial and the allocation of the cost in parallel, informing the meeting. With AmministraPro the denial, the observations, the appraisal and the complaints stay in the loss record linked to the accounting that generates the allocation; the features are on /funzioni and the plans on /prezzi.
Try AmministraPro
Accounting, thousandths-based cost splitting, meetings, communications and artificial intelligence in a single Italian software, compliant with UNI 10801 and GDPR.