Practical guide
How to request an own-party appraisal in a condominium claim
The own-party appraisal is the technical assessment that the condominium commissions from its own trusted expert to establish the causes and extent of damage, independently of the expert appointed by the insurance company. It is useful when the insurer's estimate appears too low, when the claim denial seems unfounded, or when the cause of the damage is disputed and a solid technical assessment is needed to support the condominium's position. It is not a document required by law, but a tool of defence: a well-made own-party appraisal counterbalances that of the insurance adjuster, feeds the observations to the company and, if the matter reaches court, constitutes technical evidence in the condominium's favour. Understanding when to request it and how to handle its cost avoids spending in vain and strengthens the negotiation.
When and how to activate the own-party appraisal
- Assess the gap between the damage claimed and the amount offered by the company
- Check whether the policy provides the contractual appraisal procedure
- Identify an expert qualified for the type of damage (building, systems)
- Give the expert the complete file: claim, photos, company's report
- Agree mandate, timing and cost of the appraisal before the assignment
- Resolve on the cost at the meeting when it is not among the urgent acts
- Use the appraisal for the observations, the complaint or any lawsuit
When an own-party appraisal is worthwhile
The own-party appraisal has a cost, so it should be activated when the potential benefit justifies it. The typical cases are three: a significant gap between the actual damage and the amount offered by the company, a claim denial that appears unfounded, or a dispute over the cause of the damage, for example whether it comes from a common part or a private unit. In all these cases an independent technical assessment can shift the outcome in the condominium's favour.
Conversely, for damage of modest size or when the company's assessment appears reasonable, the cost of the appraisal may exceed the advantage. The choice should be made by comparing the amount at stake with the appraisal cost and with the strength of the evidence already available. An initial informal technical consultation can help decide whether it is worth proceeding with a formal appraisal.
Own-party appraisal and contractual appraisal: do not confuse them
The own-party appraisal must be distinguished from the contractual appraisal procedure provided by many policies. The own-party appraisal is the assessment the condominium commissions independently from its own technician, and it serves to support its position in the negotiation or in court. The contractual appraisal, instead, is a mechanism provided by the contract to resolve disagreements over quantification: each party appoints an expert and the two, in case of divergence, appoint a third, whose assessment is binding within the limits set by the policy.
Knowing which tool the contract offers is important: if the policy provides the contractual appraisal, that is often the fastest and cheapest way to overcome a disagreement over the estimate, while the own-party appraisal remains the typical tool when the denial of coverage is challenged or legal action is prepared. The two can also coexist, with the own-party expert assisting the condominium in the contractual procedure.
What a useful appraisal must contain
An effective own-party appraisal is not a simple quote. It must describe the state of the premises, reconstruct the dynamics and the cause of the damage with technical reasoning, quantify the damage with reasoned criteria and, where relevant, engage with the conclusions of the company's expert, explaining where and why they diverge. Photographs, surveys and references to repair quotes strengthen its credibility.
For the appraisal to carry weight, the expert must be able to work on a complete file: claim, dated photos of the damage, inspection report, the company's appraisal report and quotes. Providing incomplete documentation produces a weak appraisal, easily attacked. That is why the quality of the evidence gathering done upstream directly reflects on the strength of the own-party appraisal.
Who pays for the appraisal and how to resolve on it
The cost of the own-party appraisal is, in the first instance, a condominium expense. When it is not among the urgent acts protecting the common parts that the manager can order under Article 1130 of the Italian Civil Code, it is advisable for the meeting to resolve on the assignment and the related expense, especially if linked to the start of a challenge or a lawsuit. In case of a favourable outcome, appraisal costs may in certain cases be recovered from the company or reimbursed in court, but this must be assessed case by case.
Handling the appraisal in an orderly way, from the expert's quote to the final report, allows the expense to be reported and the document to be used in the following steps. With AmministraPro the manager links the own-party appraisal to the loss record, together with the company's report and the observations submitted, and records its cost in the condominium's accounts ready for the allocation or for any recovery. Having everything in a single file makes the negotiation and the litigation more solid. The features are described on /funzioni and the plans on /prezzi.
Frequently asked questions
What is the own-party appraisal and what is it for?
It is the technical assessment the condominium commissions from its own trusted expert to establish the causes and extent of damage independently of the expert appointed by the company. It is useful when the insurer's estimate appears too low, when the claim denial seems unfounded or when the cause of the damage is disputed. It is not required by law, but it is a tool of defence: it counterbalances the insurance adjuster's assessment, supports the observations to the company and constitutes technical evidence if the matter reaches court.
What is the difference between own-party appraisal and contractual appraisal?
The own-party appraisal is the assessment the condominium commissions independently from its own technician to support its position. The contractual appraisal is instead a mechanism provided by many policies to resolve disagreements over quantification: each party appoints an expert and, in case of divergence, the two appoint a third, whose assessment is binding within the limits set by the contract. If the policy provides the contractual appraisal, it is often the fastest way to overcome a disagreement over the estimate; the own-party appraisal remains the typical tool when the denial is challenged or a lawsuit is prepared.
When is it worth requesting an own-party appraisal?
It is worth it when the potential benefit justifies the cost: a significant gap between the actual damage and the amount offered by the company, a claim denial that appears unfounded, or a dispute over the cause of the damage. For modest damage or when the company's assessment appears reasonable, the cost of the appraisal may exceed the advantage. The choice should be made by comparing the amount at stake with the appraisal cost and the available evidence; an initial informal technical consultation can help decide whether to proceed with a formal appraisal.
Who pays for the own-party appraisal in a condominium?
The cost is, in the first instance, a condominium expense. When it is not among the urgent acts protecting the common parts that the manager can order under Article 1130 of the Italian Civil Code, it is advisable for the meeting to resolve on the assignment and the expense, especially if linked to a challenge or legal action. In case of a favourable outcome the appraisal costs may in certain cases be recovered from the company or reimbursed in court, but this must be assessed case by case depending on how the matter develops.
What must an own-party appraisal contain to be useful?
It must describe the state of the premises, reconstruct the dynamics and cause of the damage with technical reasoning, quantify it with reasoned criteria and, where relevant, engage with the conclusions of the company's expert, explaining where they diverge. Photographs, surveys and references to quotes strengthen its credibility. For it to carry weight, the expert must work on a complete file. With AmministraPro the manager links the own-party appraisal to the loss record and records its cost, keeping everything ready for the negotiation; the features are on /funzioni and the plans on /prezzi.
Try AmministraPro
Accounting, thousandths-based cost splitting, meetings, communications and artificial intelligence in a single Italian software, compliant with UNI 10801 and GDPR.