Sending the minutes to absentees and the challenge deadline

Why the minutes must be communicated to absentees

Voidable meeting resolutions are not final until the term to challenge them has elapsed. Article 1137 of the Italian Civil Code provides that against resolutions contrary to the law or the rules, any absent, dissenting or abstaining owner may apply to the court within thirty days. The term does not start at the same moment for everyone.

For the absent owner the term runs from the communication of the resolution. Until the minutes are communicated to them, the term does not begin and the resolution stays exposed to challenge indefinitely. Sending the minutes to absentees serves precisely to start the thirty-day clock and thus to consolidate the decisions.

Different start for present and absent owners

The distinction is clear. For present owners who voted against or abstained, the thirty-day term runs from the date of the resolution, because they were at the meeting and learned of the decision when it was adopted. For absent owners, instead, the term runs from the communication of the minutes.

This asymmetry has a practical consequence: the stability of the resolution depends on the last relevant event. If even one absentee does not receive the minutes, for them the term does not run and the resolution stays challengeable. That is why communication to absentees is not a marginal formality but the condition for making the meeting's decisions certain over time.

Who to send to and by what means

The minutes must be sent to owners who were neither present nor represented by proxy. Since what matters is starting the term, the means must allow proof of the communication date: registered mail with return receipt, PEC with delivery receipt or hand delivery with signature are the suitable means.

As with the convocation, the logic of the notice requiring receipt applies: the communication takes effect when it reaches the recipient's address and the presumption of knowledge operates. A delivery without a date certification leaves uncertainty about when the thirty days start, which is exactly what you want to fix precisely.

Documenting delivery and the date

Proof of the communication of the minutes must be kept together with the minutes themselves and linked to the meeting date. In case of a challenge, this documentation will establish whether the absent owner's application is timely or late. An orderly archive makes it possible to retrieve the communication date for each recipient immediately.

It is worth distinguishing the sending of the minutes from mere posting on the noticeboard or in the private area: to start the term with certainty toward the absentee, a traceable and addressed communication is needed, not just making the document available. The noticeboard informs, but the proof of the start date is built with the suitable means.

Handling minutes and proof with the management system

Coordinating the drafting of the minutes, the identification of absentees and traceable delivery is easier with a tool that keeps the three steps together. The system knows who was present, who was represented by proxy and who was absent, and sends the minutes recording the receipt for each recipient.

With AmministraPro the minutes are drawn up, archived and sent to absentees while keeping proof of the communication date, so you can check at any time when the thirty days run. The features are described at /funzioni and the plans at /prezzi.

Frequently asked questions